Both prices and calendar spreads have been in a downtrend since May, with the decline accelerating from the middle of September, but the rally this month has reversed some of the most recent losses.
Until recently, hedge funds had become progressively less optimistic about the outlook for gas prices this winter.
Hedge funds and other money managers cut their net long position in the two main futures and options contracts by almost half to 1,408 bcf by the end of October from 2,693 bcf in September.
Portfolio managers held just 1.58 long positions for every short on Oct. 31, compared with 2.93 on Sept. 19, and the lowest ratio for almost a year.
But there appears to have been a reappraisal since the start of the month amid signs this positioning had overshot on the bearish side.
Part of the reassessment has come from recent weather patterns which have been mildly positive for gas demand.
Significantly warmer than average temperatures in late September and early October, followed by a slightly colder than average late October and early November, have boosted cooling and heating demand respectively.
But stocks have been tightening fairly consistently compared with the five-year average since the first week of March in a sign the market is persistently undersupplied.
Working stocks in underground storage have built more slowly than the five-year average in 21 out of the last 31 weeks.
The volume of working gas in storage has risen by just 1,728 billion cubic feet since the start of April compared with an average of 2,074 bcf in the previous five years.
Stocks have swung from a surplus of almost 400 billion cubic feet over the five-year average at the start of March to a deficit of 70 billion cubic feet by Nov. 3.
The market is tighter than it appears because the underlying demand for gas is much higher than five years ago as a result of LNG exports and the growing number of gas-fired power plants.
Bearish hedge fund managers point to strong growth in gas output especially from the prolific Marcellus and Utica shales.
But production has failed to keep up with consumption and exports for the last eight months despite comparatively mild temperatures.
And the number of rigs drilling for gas has fallen by almost 12 percent since the end of July indicating prices had fallen too low to sustain current activity.
The last two winters were mild overall compared with the long-term average which significantly conserved stocks but there is no guarantee the coming winter will be the same.
Overall, gas traders appear to have concluded the former bearishness had gone too far, with the recent rise in prices and spreads correcting that to a more neutral stance.
“U.S. natural gas prices under pressure even as stocks tighten”, Reuters, Oct. 23
“U.S. natural gas prices rise as winter stocks look tight”, Reuters, Sept. 19 (Reporting by John Kemp; editing by Edmund Blair)
© Reuters News 2017