It isn't a trade deal yet, but initial market reaction has been acting like it is

There was an initial sigh of relief following the announcement that the US and China had reached what US Treasury Secretary Mnuchin said was “a fundamental understanding on the key issues” last week, and had been preceded by diminished hopes when the two sides engaged in tit-for-tat action against companies on both sides of the Pacific prior to the US president-Chinese vice premier handshake. Items in the preliminary unsigned agreement included Chinese purchases of up to $50bn worth of US farm products, accepting more American financial services in their markets, and more transparency in how it sets the value of its currency, the yuan. US financial stocks relatively outperformed late last week on the news, and the Chinese have allowed the yuan to strengthen against the dollar for consecutive sessions. In turn, the October 15th US tariff hike on $250bn worth of Chinese imports from 25% to 30% has been suspended. And while the initial reaction in the financial markets has been positive and showing signs of increased risk appetite that usually involves equities surging and bond yields rising off the low while safe haven products like gold and the Japanese yen take a hit, the moves have been more cautious in light of the details – or lack thereof – involved in the tentative agreement. For starters, it’s a ‘phase one’ deal that certainly isn’t comprehensive and doesn’t address all the significant underlying issues (strategic or otherwise). Second, it hasn’t been inked on paper, and could take weeks to get it into writing and signed. And third, the Chinese while not pessimistic about the latest developments have been far less optimistic than US President Trump’s ‘lovefest’ view. Swift agreements weren’t expected to begin with, especially taking into consideration how long it took to form a US-Japan trade agreement that is in itself limited and doesn’t address main issues like auto tariffs and is formed between countries that are allies. That runs in stark contrast with the US and China who are ‘strategic competitors.’ For China, any halting of tariff hikes would be a sigh of relief for its manufacturers suffering from contraction and weakening global demand, but uncertainty would still permeate given they still export at a relative disadvantage to other countries’ manufacturing hubs that sidestep the tariffs, unless and until the US removes those tariffs. For the US, the announcement of Chinese agricultural purchases is a boost in the arm for US farmers – who form a part of President Trump’s popular base – struggling to get by on plummeting demand and a previous lack of access to the Chinese market. In all, and in the absence of any signed agreement followed by concrete action to deescalate the current US-China trade war, an optimistic view would be to consider it a temporary trade truce that certainly is a step in the right direction, but fails to address key underlying concerns and that with the significant tariffs still in place, will still force companies to consider shifting away from China as a manufacturing hub, and further cause a decoupling of the US-Chinese economies over the longer term. The uncertainty then, hasn’t been removed, but has resulted in a reduction in potential damage to the world’s two largest economies. * Any opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational purposes only. The content does not provide tax, legal or investment advice or opinion regarding the suitability, value or profitability of any particular security, portfolio or investment strategy. Read our full disclaimer policy here. © Opinion 2019

It isn't a trade deal yet, but initial market reaction has been acting like it is

DISCOVER MORE

Mideast Stocks: Gulf stocks rise as sentiment improves amid easing banking fears

Russia says oil sales to India soar amid Ukraine conflict

Oil prices soften; banking crisis and Chinese demand in focus

European stocks extend recovery as banking fears ebb

Telecom Egypt's board increases cash dividends for 2022

Orascom Financial Holding posts higher consolidated losses in 2022

UAE: Salama announces over 22% capital cut

Saudi: Sinad Holding turns profitable in 2022; accumulated losses announced

Egypt's central bank likely to hike interest rates by 3% - HSBC

UAE exchange firm Al Ansari raises $210mln in IPO

Saudi National Bank's chairman resigns; Al Ghamdi takes over

UAE's Aldar to build new flats, penthouses dedicated to holistic health, wellbeing

Saudi Al Rajhi Bank to issue dollar-denominated sustainable sukuk

The revenge of supply

Hard questions deserve more than easy answers

U.S. removing migrants from Texas border camp, begins flights to Haiti

Japan's Suga pledges not to wage war again as ministers visit controversial shrine

US aims to pass Russia, China in vaccine diplomacy race

LATEST VIDEO

VIDEO: LSE-listing will facilitate more funding opportunities for us, Dar Global CEO

ZAWYA COVERAGE

Global energy transition needs $35trln investment by 2030 – IRENA

Saudi’s fintech sector starts to rival UAE, Egypt as number of firms nearly doubles

BP and UAE's ADNOC bid for stake in NewMed Energy

UAE banking sector to remain stable in 2023 – KPMG

Sharks, tourists jostle for space around Thai destination island

Mideast Stocks: Gulf stocks rise as sentiment improves amid easing banking fears

Borouge supplies materials worth $32.69mln for mega projects in Middle East and Africa

Dubai Airports recognised as one of Best Employer Brands in LinkedIn MENA Talent Awards

Investment needs of $35trln by 2030 for successful energy transition: report

THE BRI REPORT

China is reshaping the Belt and Road Initiative ahead of a post-pandemic era

DISCOVER MORE

LATEST VIDEO

ZAWYA NEWSLETTERS

ZAWYA COVERAGE