Despite stupendous win on Adani, India short-selling boom unlikely

SINGAPORE/NEW YORK: Hindenburg Research's spectacular short bet against India's Adani group could lead other investors to consider using similar strategies in the South Asian nation but regulatory hurdles and shareholding constraints will make them tough to implement. U.S.-based Hindenburg revealed a short position last month in the ports-to-cement conglomerate, alleging improper use of offshore tax havens and stock manipulation by the group, which Adani denies. The report and its aftermath wiped out $110 billion from Adani's listed stocks in slightly more than a week, and its flagship Adani Enterprises was forced to abandon a $2.5 billion stock offering. Short sellers typically sell borrowed securities and aim to buy these back at a lower price. Opaque corporate ownership, poor governance and weak regulatory oversight make Asia, including India and China, a tempting opportunity for short-sellers, said analysts and investors. Hindenburg's bold bet against Adani could be seen as a template to its peers, as short-sellers look beyond the traditional markets for new targets that have seen a meteoric rise in stock values in the last few years. "The report and subsequent media coverage means that a variety of investors who haven't been present in India may start looking at India," said Shriram Subramanian, founder of Bengaluru-based corporate governance and proxy advisory firm InGovern Research Services. It is rare for investors to take short positions in securities of Indian companies. New York-based Hindenburg's position on Adani is the first such high-profile case in the last few decades. "Many companies are promoter or founder led companies and they hold a high percentage of the shareholding," said Sharmila Gopinath, specialist adviser to the Asian Corporate Governance Association. "And while short selling is a way to keep a check on controlling shareholders, companies with a good story would always be able fend them off." CHALLENGES Most regulators in Asia take a dim view of short attacks by foreign companies in their respective markets, at times accusing them of manipulating markets and trying to engineer a crash for their own monetary gains. "We see this time and again in developing markets that the local culture and rules of law are far from what western investors are used to," said Carson Block, founder of Muddy Waters Research and a prominent short seller. In India, for example, naked short-selling, which involves selling shares without first borrowing them, is not permitted. Such positions are possible in some developed markets. Securities rules in India also make it hard to quietly build short positions. Institutional investors are obliged to disclose their short positions upfront and there are other restrictions and registration requirements on foreign investors. "The key for short sellers to earn profits depends on how capably they can establish the short position before others are aware of bad news," said Rencheng Wang, an associate professor of accounting at Singapore Management University. Other major challenges for short-sellers in India include very high founder ownership, resulting in fewer investors available to borrow shares from, and very few companies having a deep pool of offshore securities, analysts say. In Adani, for example, Hindenburg held the short positions through U.S.-traded bonds and non-Indian-traded derivatives. "Because India, like many other emerging markets, constrains short selling, this limits the incentives for short-sellers to engage in public short campaigns in these markets," said Herve Stolowy and Luc Paugam, professors of accounting and management control at business school HEC Paris. As a result, short-sellers have had limited success in Asia. China's strict investment rules make it all but impossible to take short positions in domestic-listed Chinese stocks from overseas. Hong Kong shares which are targetted in short attacks can request a trading halt, limiting the potential damage. Referring to the Adani development, Andrew Left, founder of U.S.-based short-seller Citron Research, said India now needed to decide whether it wanted to be like China or the United States. "If it is China, then they will pursue Anderson and investigate him for wrongdoing," Left said, referring to Hindenburg's founder Nathan Anderson. "If it is the United States, regulators will look at Adani." Left himself was banned from Hong Kong's market for five years in 2016 after he was found culpable of market misconduct related to the publication of a critical research report on property developer China Evergrande Group, whose liquidity troubles two years ago fuelled a property sector crisis in the mainland. (Reporting by Anshuman Daga in Singapore, Scott Murdoch in Sydney, and Svea Herbst-Bayliss in New York; Editing by Sumeet Chatterjee and Muralikumar Anantharaman)

Despite stupendous win on Adani, India short-selling boom unlikely

DISCOVER MORE

India's NSE rolls back 6% hike in transaction charges on equity cash, derivatives

Mideast Stocks: UAE equities extend losses on ex-dividend stocks, bearish mood

Ongoing banking worries mean no respite for world stocks

Sri Lankan shares end higher as financial, consumer discretionary stocks rise

Stocks gain anew as small rate hikes loom: Philippines

Abu Dhabi's ADNOC gears up for June listing of marine & logistics unit - sources

Markets reverse after recent gains as bank fears linger

Miners, banks drag London stock lower at open

UAE exchange firm Al Ansari upsizes IPO on strong investor demand

Dubai's Emirates expands training fleet with $4.3mln aircraft order

2 African development banks invest $16bln in oil, gas projects

GCC central banks track US Fed move; hike key rates by 25bps

UAE's Presight AI to debut on Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange next week

UAE's Presight AI to debut on Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange next week

Dubai's DEPA posts higher revenue for 2022 on post-COVID recovery

Indian shares fall amid banking concerns; IT stocks rebound

Billionaire Ambani adopts familiar playbook in India cola battle vs Coke, Pepsi

Fed pause before European peers to lift Treasuries, European stocks

LATEST VIDEO

VIDEO: LSE-listing will facilitate more funding opportunities for us, Dar Global CEO

ZAWYA COVERAGE

Will gold face more downside or upside after Fed's rate hike?

Kenya signs $250mln deal with UK to boost food production

PODCAST: IFC is ready to back governments privatisation plans with capital

UAE's Presight AI to debut on Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange next week

UAE jobs: Fines, imprisonment for revealing employer's secrets

Ramadan in UAE: Getting headaches while fasting? Experts share tips to avoid

UAE weather: Temperatures to rise today, cloudy skies tonight

Guinea-Bissau upset Nigeria, Morocco reach finals in Nations Cup qualifying

Intel co-founder Gordon Moore, prophet of the rise of the PC, dies at 94

THE BRI REPORT

China is reshaping the Belt and Road Initiative ahead of a post-pandemic era

DISCOVER MORE

LATEST VIDEO

ZAWYA NEWSLETTERS

ZAWYA COVERAGE