| 29 Jul 2010 |
|
Developers use "force majeure" to skip compensation
- Text size
Majority of developers in Dubai try to invoke "force majeure" provisions in their contracts to explain delays, while a very few are willing to pay compensation, according to realty experts.
"We are aware of only a handful of developers who willingly agree compensation is due for delays, whereas the majority of developers try to use the contract to invoke 'force majeure' provisions or other acts beyond the control of the developer to explain delays," Ashraf Sayed, Associate, Hadef & Partners, told Emirates 24|7.
"As a result the developers often refuse to pay compensation. The most common explanation used by developers is delay by master developers or government authorities in providing consents or delays in handover of plots in order to commence construction."
Youcef Betraoui, Managing Director, Land Sterling - MENA believes investors should be able to claim some sort of compensation particularly if they have paid the full amount of the property as delays mean a year of lost rent/investment.
Mohanad Alwadiya, Managing Director, Harbor Real Estate, adds that all really depends on the terms and conditions of the contract between the investor and the developer, but most of the developers have included in their contracts a grace period of one year or more that allows them to delay the hand over without having to bear any financial compensation or legal obligation.
Ameya Salatry, Head of Legal, Better HomesBetter Homes
, emphasizes that investors have the right to summon the developer and enquire on the delay.
"Alternatively, they may approach Real Estate Regulatory AgencyReal Estate Regulatory Agency (ReraRera) and have a notice issued to the developer."
Compensation is covered under the Civil Code and sometimes under the relevant sales contract. Sometimes under contract compensation is payable for the period from the completion date specified in the contract until the actual date of handover.
It is common to see compensation under contract to be based on Eibor/Libor, which are currently a nominal amount.
The courts usually provide for payment of compensation in the form of interest payable on monies paid till date (approximately nine per cent) and/or payment of actual losses.
Exceptional losses may also be claimed by purchasers, however this usually requires substantial proof the developer acted maliciously or in bad faith.
Under Article 386 of the Civil Code, if it becomes impossible to perform a contractual obligation, compensation shall be payable instead.
The same judgment shall be passed if a performance is delayed. It should be noted however, compensation under the Civil Code requires a notice to be served first.
Asked if contracts in Dubai do include clauses of compensation, Sayed says: "We have seen many contracts that require payment of compensation. Typically, compensation is provided for instead of termination rights for purchasers, however, we have seen examples of contracts that provide both compensation and termination rights for purchasers. It should be noted that contractual rights to compensation and actual payment of compensation by developers are two very different concepts."
and ambiguous' on compensation to be paid by the developer incase of missing deadlines of completion."
Alwadiya adds not many contracts include a clause of compensation.
"Having said that, most contracts include a clause that allows the investor to request a refund of their money after the grace period is lapsed, subject to the terms and conditions of the agreement."
Salatry says most of the contracts are developer-friendly and seldom have clauses for compensation. However, some of them have a pre-agreed clause of compensation and can be enforced by court of law in the event of default.
Asked if the property laws define the minimum or maximum compensation to be granted to investors, Sayed points to Article 389 of the Civil Code, which says if compensation is not estimated in law or in contract then the judge shall make an estimation equivalent to the actual damage suffered.
Article 390(1) of the Civil Code states the parties to a contract may pre determine the compensation by stating the same in the contract. However, Article 390(2) goes further and states that a judge at the request of either party may make the compensation equal to the damage incurred (ie. override the contract).
It is likely that in order for a purchaser to be succeed in his claim, he must evidence actual loss, he adds.
Betraoui thinks the laws are again ambiguous, adding, "There are laws regarding compensation in the case of developer finishing a property to a different size than the original area agreed... however, I have not come across compensation by the developer on missing handover deadlines."
According to Alwadiya, the compensation amount is usually left to the court to decide or unless mentioned in the contract.
Salatry adds there is no specific value defined under law and all depends on factors such as the purchase price, amount of deposit paid, and so on.
By Parag Deulgaonkar
© Emirates Business 24/7 2010
Zawya is a distributor (and not a publisher) of content supplied by third parties and subscribers. Any opinions, advice, statements, services, offers, or other information or content expressed or made available by those third parties, including information providers, subscribers or other users of the Service, are those of the respective author(s) or distributor(s) and not of the Company. The Company neither endorses nor is responsible for the accuracy or reliability of any opinion, advice or statement made on the Service by anyone other than authorized Service employee spokespersons while acting in their official capacities. The Company is not responsible for any infringement of intellectual property rights or breach of any applicable law or regulation, including regulation in relation to financial services or the distribution of financial products, defamation, data protection, telecommunications (including regulations relating to excessive use, spamming or other abusive activities) or obscene, offensive or illegal content). Under no circumstances will the Company be liable for any loss or damage caused by a member's reliance on information obtained through the Service. It is the responsibility of member to evaluate the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any information, opinion, advice or other content available through the Service. Please seek the advice of professionals, as appropriate, regarding the evaluation of any specific information, opinion, advice or other content.
Read the full Member Agreement
http://www.zawya.com/legal/NewsLetter.cfm?name=disclaimer
Loading ...
Post a Comment
Community Comments (2)
I totally agree with your comments as I am personally having very bad experience with 3 projects in which I have invested and paid almost 80-90% of the total amount and still I have not received the possession which I was supposed to get in 2008. Unfortunately we do not have any solid regulations which will support the investor and all the developers are using the blaming game for the delay in their projects. i will really appreciate if you can advice me any possibility of taking any legal action against these developers which will help hundreds of investors in Dubai.
Thanks.
How we can think even about compensation where investors are struggling to get original money from developers since last 3-4 years.Contract comes in picture where there is a justice(in time)and quick response from RERA or Developer.
1.1 Contain any material which is libelous or defamatory of any person, is obscene, offensive, hateful or inflammatory or causes damage to the reputation of any person or organisation.
1.2 Promote sexually explicit material, violence, discrimination based on race, sex, religion, nationality, disability, sexual orientation or age or any illegal activity.
1.3 Be made in breach of any legal duty owed to a third party, such as a contractual duty or a duty of confidence.
1.4 Be threatening, abuse or invade another's privacy, or cause annoyance, inconvenience or needless anxiety.
1.5 Be used to impersonate any person, to misrepresent your identity or affiliation with any person, or be likely to deceive any person.
1.6 Give the impression that they represent Zawya.
1.7 Advocate, promote or assist any unlawful act such as (by way of example only) copyright infringement or computer misuse.